Point Restriction on Deer

Pages

87 posts / 0 new
Last post
330oldsmobile's picture
330oldsmobile
Offline
Joined: 11/26/11
Point Restriction on Deer

As the opening weekend of deer season is coming to an end i have seen a lot of people that just want to be done hunting and shooting anything with antlers which really bugs me especially when the same people do this year after year and then complain they never see any big bucks. I doubt that it will happen in ND anytime soon but the thought of putting point restriction on tags might help grow bigger deer as well as help out with the low population of deer we are experiencing. I was just wondering what other people thought about this since i pass lots of bucks already this weekend up to a smaller 5x5 but never know when they cross the road the guys that drive around and road hunt won't shoot them.

huntemup's picture
huntemup
Offline
GREENHORN
Joined: 3/29/02

You have got to be kidding. Shoot whatever deer you want and be happy with it.  Let others shoot what they want.

SHEDZ's picture
SHEDZ
Offline
GREENHORN
Joined: 10/18/06

Alot of the city folk dont have the time or money to spend days looking for deer. So they shoot the first deer they see.(not saying nothing bad about city folk) Heard many people say that over the years. If i could get a damn tag i would hunt 16.5 days.

fishfinder97's picture
fishfinder97
Offline
Joined: 6/14/10

Coming from a guy who hunts for meat and to enjoy a great pastime i love let everyone shoot what they want. Its in the eye of the beholder

 "If you're too busy to Hunt and catch Fish, then you're too busy"

" The greatest feeling in life is doing what others say you can't"

doublea's picture
doublea
Offline
Joined: 9/24/05

You can't eat the horns! I think the vast majority of folks hunt deer because they want the meat for the table and the smaller, younger bucks just seem to taste better.

BowHunter1527's picture
BowHunter1527
Offline
Joined: 10/6/06

I totally disagree with you. Again you see that people here  think you need to shoot a huge deer. A trophy is what ever you want it to be, this can change day by day, hunt by hunt depending on the circumstances. Some people prefer to hunt just for the fun of sport and others like to fill the freezer. While others prefer to trophy hunt. The bottom line is as long as its ethical it who cares.

"You can be a king or a street sweeper, but everybody dances with the Grim Reaper."

I.M.predator's picture
I.M.predator
Offline
GREENHORN
Joined: 10/29/12

I agree with BH1527.  Everyone has their own reasons for hunting and have their own expectations and levels of experience.  When the've pulled the trigger they've chosen their trophy and as long as they are happy I'd say they had a successful hunt. 

With that said, I say let them shoot the first deer that comes along so we can get the rif raff out of the way.  When it comes to hunting, I've never been a fan of large crowds. 

theSting's picture
theSting
Offline
Joined: 9/8/11

No way on antler restrictions. Hunting has become to caught up with "score". Sick of it.

Go hunt, be happy with what you have and what you get.

BowHunter1527's picture
BowHunter1527
Offline
Joined: 10/6/06

I.M.predator Said:

With that said, I say let them shoot the first deer that comes along so we can get the rif raff out of the way.  When it comes to hunting, I've never been a fan of large crowds. 

 

Thats one reason why bowhunting is so much better, we dont have large crowds.

"You can be a king or a street sweeper, but everybody dances with the Grim Reaper."

buckhunter24_7's picture
buckhunter24_7
Offline
GREENHORN
Joined: 11/20/09

So when someone shoots a 4x4 with broken brow tines they just leave them in the field to rot instead of getting a fine? Sounds like a good plan

bigoats's picture
bigoats
Offline
Joined: 5/19/12

I dont think we need to make  a legal matter out of it, instead i think we just need to use better common sense. I believe that to many people shoot to young of Bucks. Just because you have a buck tag doesnt mean you should fill it by all means. Its a privelage to most to get a buck tag and when you have one dont you want the best possible chances to get a big buck. By killing deer that are two maybe three years old your taking your chances greatly down. I would rather make deer tag soup than kill a young buck. I am not a trophy hunter in any way being the biggest buck i have killed went just over 160. I just feel we should let the younger deer live and if you dont get the one your after this year, well then you will be that much more pumped up for next year to roll around, the buck you were after will be bigger and so will the rest of the deer.

I guess: It’s a tale told by an idiot, full of sound and fury, signifying nothing.
                                                                                                     "Shakespeare"

theSting's picture
theSting
Offline
Joined: 9/8/11

Who's decision does that come down to though?

People enjoy hunting for numerous reasons. A "buck" tag doesn't mean they are out there to shoot something with huge horns. It means they are looking for a male deer. The hunter should be the one making the call on what he or she chooses to shoot. If a person hunts hard for a day or two and then wants to fill up the freezer, that should remain that persons choice.

Secondly, there are a lot of people out there that simply don't care about shooting a big buck. I'm sure like all of us its in the back of their minds but when it comes down to it they are just as happy with an animal on the ground and tagged as a "trophy" buck.

bigoats Said:
I dont think we need to make  a legal matter out of it, instead i think we just need to use better common sense. I believe that to many people shoot to young of Bucks. Just because you have a buck tag doesnt mean you should fill it by all means. Its a privelage to most to get a buck tag and when you have one dont you want the best possible chances to get a big buck. By killing deer that are two maybe three years old your taking your chances greatly down. I would rather make deer tag soup than kill a young buck. I am not a trophy hunter in any way being the biggest buck i have killed went just over 160. I just feel we should let the younger deer live and if you dont get the one your after this year, well then you will be that much more pumped up for next year to roll around, the buck you were after will be bigger and so will the rest of the deer.
bckhntr's picture
bckhntr
Offline
GREENHORN
Joined: 11/17/04

Are you a "trophy" hunter or a meat hunter?  When it comes down to getting only 1 tag per person, a male deer will provide more meat than most does.

I'm with the rest of the crowd that says shoot what you want as long as your tag says you can!

Sometimes what is going through your head, should stay in your head!

Only crooked politicians fear armed citizens.

ARROW EM''s picture
ARROW EM'
Offline
Joined: 10/5/06

To each their own. To me, last time I checked, I am not starving to death so if I don't "fill" the freezer, that is ok with me. Beef will be in grocery stores, hell, you can even go to the meat locker and buy venison these days. I hunt for the thrill of the hunt and the most mature animal I am able. This does not mean that I want someone or some law out there telling me what I can and cannot do. We have enough government involvement in the outdoors, I don't want to see any more. I hunt for the best animal I can find and that is MY choice. Would I like to see some age class in the deer herd and see what each animals potential is? Sure. Do I and will I hunt for animals with large headgear? You bet your ass I do and will. This however does not mean that I can tell some new youth hunter or any hunter for that matter what he can or cannot shoot. If something like this came to legislation, it is possible I would be in favor of, but only if the majority agreed.

Double Lung em'

Sum1's picture
Sum1
Offline
GREENHORN
Joined: 1/12/08

huntemup Said:
You have got to be kidding. Shoot whatever deer you want and be happy with it.  Let others shoot what they want.

I agree with this message.

 "Play it Mr.Toot"

Sum1's picture
Sum1
Offline
GREENHORN
Joined: 1/12/08

How bout slot limits?

 "Play it Mr.Toot"

rbhavebeenfishin's picture
rbhavebeenfishin
Offline
Joined: 3/18/11

proven fact states that gun season falls during rut have smaller bucks. theres already to many restrictions in this country. we dont need anymore

Meelosh's picture
Meelosh
Offline
GREENHORN
Joined: 5/26/06

 Why do people insist on making others hunt "their way"? Live and let live folks. 

Is it impious to weigh goose music and art in the same scales? I think not, because the true hunter is merely a noncreative artist. Who painted the first picture on a bone in the caves of France? A hunter. Who alone in our modern life so thrills to the sight of living beauty that he will endure hunger and thirst and cold to feed his eye upon it? The hunter. Who wrote the great hunter's poem about the sheer wonder of the wind, the hail, and the snow, the stars, the lightnings, and the clouds, the lion, the deer, and the wild goat, the raven, the hawk, and the eagle, and above all the eulogy to the horse? Job, one of the great dramatic artists of all time. Poets sing and hunters scale the mountains primarily for one and the same reason--the thrill of beauty. Critics write and hunters outwit their game primarily for one and the same reason--to reduce that beauty to possession. The differences are largely matters of degree, consciousness, and that sly arbiter of the classification of human activities, language. If, then, we can live without goose music, we may as well do away with stars, or sunsets, or Iliads. But the point is we would be fools to do away with any of them. 

SHORTHAIRSRUS's picture
SHORTHAIRSRUS
Offline
GREENHORN
Joined: 11/24/04

some of us just want to eat

Stay thirsty my friends

snowgoosehunter09's picture
snowgoosehunter09
Offline
GREENHORN
Joined: 4/3/09

 

BowHunter1527 Said:

 
Thats one reason why bowhunting is so much better, we dont have large crowds.

330oldsmobile's picture
330oldsmobile
Offline
Joined: 11/26/11

I totally get hunting for meat which is what i do also but shooting large deer is a bonus. I agree that the trophy is in the eye of the beholder but when they shoot these deer and then complain year after year about not ever shooting big deer is what i don't get when they made the decision to shoot the 1 1/2 year old deer on a yearly basis. I dont want to take away from their hunting right but thot that it might help out populations to let the next generation hunt the same way we have. And i agree that some youth hunters might be happy with a small buck when i was 11 i shot a small 4x4 and was thrilled with it and im still young (17) and have not shot another buck since but then again i am more of a trophy hunter and if i dont shoot one i shoot a doe to fill the freezer when it gets to the end of the bow season

snowgoosehunter09's picture
snowgoosehunter09
Offline
GREENHORN
Joined: 4/3/09

 

huntemup Said:
You have got to be kidding. Shoot whatever deer you want and be happy with it.  Let others shoot what they want.

Crackshot.'s picture
Crackshot.
Offline
GREENHORN
Joined: 7/14/09

Good to see there are some that hunt for the meat and realize that hunting can be funner if you take it with a grain of salt .  Shoot  what you want to shoot in my opinion.       Not everyone can afford the time or money to wait out for a big buck , And to  the guys saying don't shoot small bucks wait for a big buck ,,,,,    If everyone only shot big bucks what would we have left ?     For the record,  I usually shoot what ever buck on the farm that I don't want around.     I usually shoot one with a scrubby looking rack , Especially if I see him chasing does.  Oh thats right , Culling scrub bucks doesn't work. 

 

 

 

Life is good
 

 

 

 

greatwhitefishe's picture
greatwhitefishe
Offline
Joined: 6/6/03

 Hunting is about having fun and getting into the outdoors. Of course everyone wants a big buck, but not everyone is going to get one. I really hope you have a kid and teach him/her that hunting is about shooting big bucks only. So when he or she goes without a deer for multiple years, because the deer is not up to your standards they quit hunting... Good job! If you want bigger bucks start a game farm.

svnmag's picture
svnmag
Offline
GREENHORN
Joined: 11/3/02

FWIW, small bucks become large bucks.  Back in the day o'plenty, I put a doe in the freezer and generally ate the buck tag.  Had a ground shrinkage issue in '09; still my personal best and great thrill.  Again, IMHO.

 Nuke the Whales

Big Buck's picture
Big Buck
Offline
Joined: 12/5/02

Most of the hunter wantabes usually shoot there big forkhorn out the window of the pickup becuase there to lazy to put the time in to kill a mature buck. They could just as well go buy some pork and save the deer

Cowbell's picture
Cowbell
Offline
GREENHORN
Joined: 8/15/06

So let me get this straight. You are a 17 year old kid who has shot exactly one buck in his life, and now you want to revamp the system.
Yeah, this is going to end well.

shooter08's picture
shooter08
Offline
Joined: 5/5/08

Sounds like 330 Oldsmobile has been watching too many hunting shows and reading too many magazines. Don't forget the reason for hunting is for the enjoyment of the outdoors, fun with family and friends, and thrill of the hunt. Thank the Lord most of us don't have to hunt to survive like the old days. I like the idea of trophy hunting for myself, but not at the expense of the freedoms of others. To each their own. You want to create your own rules about trophy hunting? Buy up some acres, plant food plots, get your gratis, and try to manage a herd on your own dime and labors. Of course with land prices thats pretty much impossible...........

fishfinder97's picture
fishfinder97
Offline
Joined: 6/14/10

I don't see why everyone gets so hyped up about antler score. Do I go to the local buck show and check it all out?? Of course, It's always great to hear everyones stories and experiences they had over the season. I know i'm not the only 1 but I really like a big plump corn fed whitetail. I have seen some really heavy bodied fork bucks and small basket racks and that means a winter of real good eating. If someone pulls the trigger on a deer its what they want so congratulate them don't come down on them.

 "If you're too busy to Hunt and catch Fish, then you're too busy"

" The greatest feeling in life is doing what others say you can't"

johnr's picture
johnr
Offline
GREENHORN
Joined: 2/18/04

26 seasons of deer rifle hunting, some of them with 2 tags. I have never eaten a tag sandwich on any of my tags. With that being said I have had plenty of doe seasons, and plenty of fairly small buck seasons.

I have a few heads on the wall, I typically hunt within an hour or less of home, have a job that I can take the time whenever I need to, and have many farm/ranch friends that give me access to their land at almost all times. With that being said, not always are the big bucks around. I enjoy the hunt, the butchering, the meat, the jerky, the entire experience. I would hate for my kids to have to feel bad for not getting a big buck, or eating a tag sandwich because the ones they had opportunities with were to small.

Its like fishing in the boat, I have cleaned some fairly small fish, because the kids wanted to keep what they caught. Its the times you have with them that counts not the trophy that might end up on the wall.

Neat

Captain Ahab's picture
Captain Ahab
Offline
GREENHORN
Joined: 12/1/08

I had a long conversation about this the other night.  I see both sides of the argument and have feelings both ways.  ND has always been managed for opportunity rather than a trophy status state.  I doubt that will change any time soon.  I would rather shoot a trophy and buy some beef than shoot a young one for the table, but I also don't want to take opportunity away from others that pursue it for what it is(a time to spend outdoors with family and friends).  I can see a lot of problems with a point/tine limit with deer shot that ground shrink into a violation.  It also makes a trophy that much more rare and special.  Right now your best bet for a trophy is go to a trophy state as I doubt we are moving towards that way of management.

"Diligence is the mother of good luck."

"The constitution only gives people the right to pursue hapiness.  You have to catch it yourself."

"Well done is better than well said."

"Beer is living proof that God loves us and wants us to be happy."

All by:  Benjamin Franklin.

"The solution to any problem - work, love, money, whatever - is to go fishing, and the bigger the problem, the longer the trip should be."

Author: John Gierach

Pages