Hunting Fishing Discussions

Featured Outdoor Businesses

Dakota Tackle
Bismarck, ND


Share on Facebook subscribe feed

Giving Up

by , Posted to on 11/17/2010 8:59 PM | "Quote" | "Quick Reply" |

Joined: 12/17/2004
Location: ND
Not sure If I've ever started a thread but I've been reading some of the others and it just confirms how I feel about the rifle season. The replies from some will be predictable no doubt as the divide is large in many areas, especially landowners/non-landowners. I'll start by saying I am not a landowner and understand that side very well. I very much appreciate the ability to hunt on ground that is not posted. I've made good friends meeting landowners and happen to have a best friend with a lot of ground. Being from Colorado where everything is assumed private really gave me an appreciation for being here. It was amazing several years ago and between that and the great people, I'm proud to call this home.

The last several years I've watched the steady decline in this relationship, and I'm afraid that the snowball is rolling down the hill, gaining momentum, speed, and size. As the divide grows, more land is posted and with the things I've seen, I can't blame them one bit. As more land is posted, more people like myself and many others, are forced to drive around looking for those few places available racing the rest of the crowd. A portion of those folks then push the boundaries in all the ways we hear about every day. The landownders get more angry and post more ground and so it goes.

My best friend had never turned anyone in until this year. It just plain got to be too much, and now he is calling every time. The unfortunate thing is that in this case, which is not unlike many I think, he only posts 5 quarters that several of us hunt on, out of several full sections that are wide open. This season alone, I've personally seen 2 cases of people driving in the middle of the CRP(that we caught), 3 does laid on the approach right by posted signs, with just the hind quarters gone, no tags and didn't even take the backstraps. Multiple signs down, including the wooden posts that were broken off that we spent Sunday re-planting. The deer I personally was stalking to within 400 yds shot from the road and thrown in the truck in record time. At least 3 times people driving in the field shooting out of the window. Multiple shots from truck windows right by us. 2 guys pushing the one set of trees the landowner has never walked and shooting at the deer running past his one tower blind while he and his 3 year old were in it.

This is not exaggeration, this is what I've seen just this season. Now, what's the natural progression? He starts calling the game warden, people get turned in, and of course, he posts everything else, and so the cycle continues. I feel so bad just watching it all. It's like watching a car accident where everyone is hurt but in slow motion and with perfect clarity. It just plain sucks.

I'll tell ya, the main point of my post was to say that I don't have the answer for this. I'm afraid this relationship will never get fixed and will only get worse. I also know that this is not the majority of hunters but boy do the bad ones really stand out. The only thing I can think of is huge fines. Anyway, I for one have put the rifle away with a tag yet in my pocket. Rifle season just isn't any fun anymore, at least it sure wasn't this year. This isn't how it's supposed to be. Stick to the bow and enjoy the quiet from now on for me. sorry for the long rant.
Re: Giving Up
by on 11/17/2010 9:20 PM | Reply #1 | "Quote" | "Quick Reply" |

Joined: 10/24/2005
Location: ND
I've seen a lot of the same type of crap... it sucks. Not sure how to help stop the "rolling" effect.
 I look at it a  LOT of ways... some of the issue is big land barons who don't care about anything else but their land... some dumb-arsed neighbors of the landowners tearing things up and blaming it on hunters....
then you have the legitimate moron hunters who shouldn't be allowed in the field, because their practices are BEYOND shady.

Granted, there are a LOT of good landowners, and probably the same amount of good hunters...

Guess the best thing anybody can do, if youd like to hunt private or leased state land is to treat the farmers/ranchers/landowners with a good amount of respect... hell, its not even about hunting.
Do you leave garbage or tear up YOUR neighbors property? Probably not.. It's common courtesy. If they don't allow you to hunt, smile.... thank them for their time and be on your way.... don't pop the first thing that moves 15 yards off their posted signs in retaliation... I have also seen landowners all but shoot you for even asking about hunting on their property... And some seem to post their property for political reasons...
I saw a FLOOD of new posted signs when Rick Berg threw out Pomeroy... since when should hunting have a DAMN thing to do with politics? Grow up.



Regardless of IF you own land, or just pounding dirt looking for game...
treat each other with respect.... otherwise both sides will be screwed...
Retaliation from both sides,taxes,etc... you name it... nothing good comes out of this unless we all have a cranial rectal inversion.... FAST.





I'm the devil's son..... call me young gun.

Re: Giving Up
by on 11/17/2010 9:26 PM | Reply #2 | "Quote" | "Quick Reply" |

Joined: 12/21/2003
Location: ND
Jokostel,

Since when does it matter why a person posts his property??  And why should you care...maybe you need to grow up a bit??
Re: Giving Up
by on 11/17/2010 9:29 PM | Reply #3 | "Quote" | "Quick Reply" |

Joined: 10/24/2005
Location: ND
Little Elvis Said:
Jokostel,

Since when does it matter why a person posts his property??  And why should you care...maybe you need to grow up a bit??

 I could care less how why.... it's their perogative.
I can still state my opinion... I simply don't care if people agree or not...
Kinda whats great about out country...
And I should grow up? I would agree to that If I said that you could kiss my conservative ass...
Oh wait..



I'm the devil's son..... call me young gun.

Re: Giving Up
by on 11/17/2010 9:38 PM | Reply #4 | "Quote" | "Quick Reply" |

Joined: 10/18/2006
Location: ND
i12fish Said:
Not sure If I've ever started a thread but I've been reading some of the others and it just confirms how I feel about the rifle season. The replies from some will be predictable no doubt as the divide is large in many areas, especially landowners/non-landowners. I'll start by saying I am not a landowner and understand that side very well. I very much appreciate the ability to hunt on ground that is not posted. I've made good friends meeting landowners and happen to have a best friend with a lot of ground. Being from Colorado where everything is assumed private really gave me an appreciation for being here. It was amazing several years ago and between that and the great people, I'm proud to call this home.

The last several years I've watched the steady decline in this relationship, and I'm afraid that the snowball is rolling down the hill, gaining momentum, speed, and size. As the divide grows, more land is posted and with the things I've seen, I can't blame them one bit. As more land is posted, more people like myself and many others, are forced to drive around looking for those few places available racing the rest of the crowd. A portion of those folks then push the boundaries in all the ways we hear about every day. The landownders get more angry and post more ground and so it goes.

My best friend had never turned anyone in until this year. It just plain got to be too much, and now he is calling every time. The unfortunate thing is that in this case, which is not unlike many I think, he only posts 5 quarters that several of us hunt on, out of several full sections that are wide open. This season alone, I've personally seen 2 cases of people driving in the middle of the CRP(that we caught), 3 does laid on the approach right by posted signs, with just the hind quarters gone, no tags and didn't even take the backstraps. Multiple signs down, including the wooden posts that were broken off that we spent Sunday re-planting. The deer I personally was stalking to within 400 yds shot from the road and thrown in the truck in record time. At least 3 times people driving in the field shooting out of the window. Multiple shots from truck windows right by us. 2 guys pushing the one set of trees the landowner has never walked and shooting at the deer running past his one tower blind while he and his 3 year old were in it.

This is not exaggeration, this is what I've seen just this season. Now, what's the natural progression? He starts calling the game warden, people get turned in, and of course, he posts everything else, and so the cycle continues. I feel so bad just watching it all. It's like watching a car accident where everyone is hurt but in slow motion and with perfect clarity. It just plain sucks.

I'll tell ya, the main point of my post was to say that I don't have the answer for this. I'm afraid this relationship will never get fixed and will only get worse. I also know that this is not the majority of hunters but boy do the bad ones really stand out. The only thing I can think of is huge fines. Anyway, I for one have put the rifle away with a tag yet in my pocket. Rifle season just isn't any fun anymore, at least it sure wasn't this year. This isn't how it's supposed to be. Stick to the bow and enjoy the quiet from now on for me. sorry for the long rant.

Good post. I think the more land that gets posted the more of these acts your going to see. Its only going to get worse my freind. People dont care about other peoples property or anything else. None land owners are getting tired of all the posted land with no were to go i'd say.
Re: Giving Up
by on 11/17/2010 9:54 PM | Reply #5 | "Quote" | "Quick Reply" |

Joined: 09/11/2009
Location: nd
13 years ago is the last time I applied for a gun permit for whitetail deer.  13 years ago is when I purchased my first bow.
I have not experience what you (fish) have stated nor what people have stated on the gratis site.  I hope the bad is not to the degree that has been said. 
For me the reason to put the gun away is because I tried bow hunting.  It is a whole different world than hunting with a gun.
Today I lefted earlier from work.  Took my bow, picked up my trailcam on the way to the stand, once in the stand took off my jacket, sat up my video camera and bow, turn the heater on, put on my head set to listen to janis and jimmy, sat down in my chair, look at the pictures and played some cards while I watched the snowflakes fall.
And then some of my buddies came from the trees, they let me video them and I did have a conversation with them. Maybe onesided but still a great conversation.
Yes, I have lost my ability to kill but in all the years of gun hunting (and there were fun times) I never enjoy the peace of mind or had the enjoyment I have had by bow hunting.
Now it seems everybody has a crappy remark to say about others statements (elvis).  It may be that there still upset about that house falling on their sister some time ago.
But life is great. 
My good friend and buddy, because of November 2, will soon be unemployed. There is a person who is looking to go back to California due to measure 2.  Bristol Palin keeps winning.  What more can I have.  And for whatever reason I have found a lot of peace.  Maybe it is the bow. 
thanks db 
Re: Giving Up
by on 11/17/2010 9:55 PM | Reply #6 | "Quote" | "Quick Reply" |

Joined: 11/17/2010
Location: ND
I agree I give up on rifle season and let all the idiots shoot each other and enjoy the peacefull bow hunting!!
Re: Giving Up
by on 11/17/2010 10:21 PM | Reply #7 | "Quote" | "Quick Reply" |

Joined: 11/24/2004
Location: ND
whew - I thought drayweb started a thread about his elk --- keep huntin dray
Stay thirsty my friends
Re: Giving Up
by on 11/17/2010 10:44 PM | Reply #8 | "Quote" | "Quick Reply" |

Joined: 11/24/2004
Location: ND

What really is happening -   Price of crops went up, CRP went down, Deer numbers went down, trees and sloughs are being taken out so that more crops can be planted (tree rows), sloughs are being burnt, the G&F reduce tags slightly, greed, property becomes posted:

I dont remember the year - but I hunt north of jamestown -- -one year our farmer friend told us ---look at my neighbor he went to AZ and left his land posted - big mistake.  Herds of deer were taking refuge on his land over 100 deer.     Deer season was snowy.  It was back when the WT balooned.  Many stretches of land were unposted --- why because land owners didnt want the deer to ruin property, crops etc.  It definetly was golden.    

Herds dont exist any more. 

We had some tough winters coupled with commodity prices going up -- hence my first paragraph ----- What does this all do --- puts more pressure on the resource.   Its not like the resource doesnt exist - it does --- however the pressure comes in the form of what this thread is all about.   

   Like the recession we need it to get worse before it will get better.   Come on    La nina     
 

Stay thirsty my friends
Re: Giving Up
by on 11/17/2010 11:16 PM | Reply #9 | "Quote" | "Quick Reply" |

Joined: 11/06/2002
Location: ND
Couple of observations as to the acts we hear about. Saw a few this past deer season and called them in as well. Only way it will stop is when word gets out that Barney got pinched for something everyone knows is wrong.

During the last 10 years especially the focus has been on trophy animals, we see it in threads on FB regarding this, be it to many tags and people complaining about the little bucks not getting a chance to grow. Then look at all the ads for trophy growth supplements,to the shows on cable and satellite TV expounding the mighty antler!

Back in my day of first starting to hunt deer with a rifle, the big buck contests where based upon the weight of an animal. Today I doubt if there is a single contest that does this for bucks.
We have a new generation of deer hunters who have never experienced low numbers of deer, or limited habitat. Friend of mine back home has a fair amount of land some in CRP and other in crop land. He has some of it posted, the rest is open to hunting. He allows others to hunt for does. Yet he is villianized by many for posting his land. They only hunt their land with a few friends.

I have thought about posting our property but then realized that it only would penalize the good hunters as the bad will not care about the signs anyway.
In my lifetime I have seen fence row to fence row farming and the return of CRP and game to the landscape.Now we face again the prosepect of fence row to fence row again! Sportsman are our own worst enemy in that we fail to look forward and focus to much on the now!
Re: Giving Up
by on 11/18/2010 02:09 AM | Reply #10 | "Quote" | "Quick Reply" |

Joined: 02/17/2002
Location: ND
yep, i agree, measure no.2 did the most harm for hunters/landowners, where there used to be a dialog between the two, now exsits a cold draft. too bad, it will never be the same ,and you guys are also right about the local trophy hunting tv shows .[it's what we do].go for the big horns only, and we are the only ones [tv show]. to take the trophys,saw one of the A team tv guys in their painted up trucks, wow, it's the new wave of huntng, kept the cameras rollinin 
Re: Giving Up
by on 11/18/2010 08:29 AM | Reply #11 | "Quote" | "Quick Reply" |

Joined: 09/11/2002
Location: ND
I think bait and trail cams are to blame as well.  Dialogue between hunters and landowners created common ground between the two.  Both groups relied on each other to find out what kind of game was out there.

There is no need to talk to each other anymore.  They watch game 24/7, and know exactly what is out there.

I say to hell with that pot o' gold.

Re: Giving Up
by on 11/18/2010 08:57 AM | Reply #12 | "Quote" | "Quick Reply" |

Joined: 09/11/2009
Location: nd
I have 1.9 acres on an old railroad line that I purchased for $500 (sold to me by a neighbor).  All the land around me is posted for at least two miles with the canadian border on the north.  There are a lot of trees along with farm land.  No roads by me.  I plant food plots (one acre) that one neighbor allow me to on part of his land next to me.  Some inbetween the trees on my land.  Turnips and rape, they just love this year.  Also corn, soybeans and canola.  Round up ready helps. I planted the turnips in earlier September.  The neighbors who live up there come to me to ask what deer are around.  They may live there and watch 24/7 but when I show them the pictures they are surprise.  As I live and work in town and do have another life besides hunting I am limited to the time I can be up there.  So please do not blame the trailcam and take it away from me.  My neighbor farmer and ranchers enjoy the pictures to.  We do visit often.  I am thankful that I am not a part nor see that world that has been describe.  Yes, I remember the days when to see any kind of a deer was a treat.  We could walk for days and not even see a doe let alone a buck.  But the last 13 years have been great.  A lot of memory, some great videos and pictures with little kills.  Part of the reason I have not even applied for a gun permit on whitetail for 13 years.
thanks db
Re: Giving Up
by on 11/18/2010 09:10 AM | Reply #13 | "Quote" | "Quick Reply" |

Joined: 12/17/2003
Location: ND
How about people making sure they have a place to hunt before applying for a tag????

People think just because they spent $20 that the state or land owners need to provide them a place to hunt.  But guess what.....they don't.

If you don't have a place to hunt before you apply for a tag, then don't cry when you are driving around during the season and you can't find a place to go.


And what the hell is with all the idiots shooting pheasants out of the pickup windows in the ditch?????   I mean are you starving to death that you have to get that rooster to survive another day???  Why the heck would you want to ground ball a pheasant out of a  moving vehicle?   I would have to take my boots off to count all the idiots that did this in just the first 2 weekends on posted land.





Re: Giving Up
by on 11/18/2010 09:10 AM | Reply #14 | "Quote" | "Quick Reply" |

Joined: 09/29/2010
Location: nd
Little Elvis Said:
Jokostel,

Since when does it matter why a person posts his property??  And why should you care...maybe you need to grow up a bit??

Tim,
why don't you stop stuff like this right away.  No reason for these threads to get out of control with comments like this.
Re: Giving Up
by on 11/18/2010 09:28 AM | Reply #15 | "Quote" | "Quick Reply" |

Joined: 02/13/2006
Location: ND
The damage caused on the prairie trails this year was bad.  I wouldn't be surprised to see more trails get disked over.  That is just one example of why the posters will get worse.

  Giving up is one option, but not mine.  Yes , there are a lot of posters to deal with, but if you keep asking sooner or later you will get some access.  It's kind of like asking a girl on a date, if you just walk up to her  and she has no idea of who you are you are probably going to get a no.  If you are introduced to her by a mutual acquaintance then you chances just went up bigtime.
Re: Giving Up
by on 11/18/2010 09:39 AM | Reply #16 | "Quote" | "Quick Reply" |

Joined: 05/05/2007
Location: MN
Go Bears Said:
Little Elvis Said:
Jokostel,

Since when does it matter why a person posts his property??  And why should you care...maybe you need to grow up a bit??

Tim,
why don't you stop stuff like this right away.  No reason for these threads to get out of control with comments like this.
i agree bear, i've mentiond elvis several times to Tim yet he is still among us
the more food you have in your mouth, the better you can taste it !!
Re: Giving Up
by on 11/18/2010 09:50 AM | Reply #17 | "Quote" | "Quick Reply" |

Joined: 04/11/2010
Location: ND
Really whitetailhunter......so just because a guy dosent have a spot to hunt he shouldnt apply for a tag. Most land dosent even get posted until right before season opener. And the public land that is out there is just getting pounded because of the amount of posted land. And every year it just seems to get worse. I have hunted all over the state this year and cannot belive the amount of land that is locked up. This state is going right down the shitter for all the hunters out there that arent fortunate enough to own land. I also understand that it is the slob hunters out there that are much to blame. But i think this is getting a little out of control. Just my opinion.....

HNTNFRK

Re: Giving Up
by on 11/18/2010 11:00 AM | Reply #18 | "Quote" | "Quick Reply" |

Joined: 11/15/2007
Location: ND
i12fish Said:
Not sure If I've ever started a thread but I've been reading some of the others and it just confirms how I feel about the rifle season. The replies from some will be predictable no doubt as the divide is large in many areas, especially landowners/non-landowners. I'll start by saying I am not a landowner and understand that side very well. I very much appreciate the ability to hunt on ground that is not posted. I've made good friends meeting landowners and happen to have a best friend with a lot of ground. Being from Colorado where everything is assumed private really gave me an appreciation for being here. It was amazing several years ago and between that and the great people, I'm proud to call this home.

The last several years I've watched the steady decline in this relationship, and I'm afraid that the snowball is rolling down the hill, gaining momentum, speed, and size. As the divide grows, more land is posted and with the things I've seen, I can't blame them one bit. As more land is posted, more people like myself and many others, are forced to drive around looking for those few places available racing the rest of the crowd. A portion of those folks then push the boundaries in all the ways we hear about every day. The landownders get more angry and post more ground and so it goes.

My best friend had never turned anyone in until this year. It just plain got to be too much, and now he is calling every time. The unfortunate thing is that in this case, which is not unlike many I think, he only posts 5 quarters that several of us hunt on, out of several full sections that are wide open. This season alone, I've personally seen 2 cases of people driving in the middle of the CRP(that we caught), 3 does laid on the approach right by posted signs, with just the hind quarters gone, no tags and didn't even take the backstraps. Multiple signs down, including the wooden posts that were broken off that we spent Sunday re-planting. The deer I personally was stalking to within 400 yds shot from the road and thrown in the truck in record time. At least 3 times people driving in the field shooting out of the window. Multiple shots from truck windows right by us. 2 guys pushing the one set of trees the landowner has never walked and shooting at the deer running past his one tower blind while he and his 3 year old were in it.

This is not exaggeration, this is what I've seen just this season. Now, what's the natural progression? He starts calling the game warden, people get turned in, and of course, he posts everything else, and so the cycle continues. I feel so bad just watching it all. It's like watching a car accident where everyone is hurt but in slow motion and with perfect clarity. It just plain sucks.

I'll tell ya, the main point of my post was to say that I don't have the answer for this. I'm afraid this relationship will never get fixed and will only get worse. I also know that this is not the majority of hunters but boy do the bad ones really stand out. The only thing I can think of is huge fines. Anyway, I for one have put the rifle away with a tag yet in my pocket. Rifle season just isn't any fun anymore, at least it sure wasn't this year. This isn't how it's supposed to be. Stick to the bow and enjoy the quiet from now on for me. sorry for the long rant.
Boy now this is reality right here.. Well played.

Re: Giving Up
by on 11/18/2010 11:14 AM | Reply #19 | "Quote" | "Quick Reply" |

Joined: 07/25/2007
Location: ND
i guess i don't see the same problems as the rest of you guys.  maybe its the area i live in.  who knows.  other than 10 years ago when i was stupid enough to go SW of Bismarck, i've never had to even bother asking permission to chase roosters.  there are plenty on public and unposted land.  and we shoot a limit pretty much every darn time we go out.  doesn't matter how many guys we go w/.  by myself or 4 of us.  from maddock to the south dakota boarder between 83 and 281 a guy can find plenty of birds w/o having to talk to a single landowner. 

waterfowling... plenty of water to hunt if you don't mind putting on waders.  nothing like late season mallards on big water after the sloughs have frozen.  or chase them off the sloughs early if you wish.  and as far as field hunting goes... its straight up awesome... and although i've only been doing it consistently for a few years, i don't think me or anyone i hunt w/ has ever been turned down when asking permission to kill birds.  maybe once or twice cause someone else already asked.  and might have been told we can't drive in a muddy one.  but, pretty much 90% of landowners couldn't care less if you want to shoot some ducks or geese out of thier harvested fields. 

deer... tis a little different... but, not much imho... where we hunt, i could walk for 2 weeks straight from sun up to sun down on public and/or unposted land w/o ever walking the same piece of land twice.  and it ain't all plowed fields.  sure you might have to deal w/ another hunter every once and a while and you might not have the same opportunity as those darn evil landowners.  but, the opportunities are there.  i've been w/ when 2 of the biggest deer i've ever seen were shot on open land (piece of state land and one unposted) the last two years.  the combination of open land and maybe one landowner relationship should keep a guy busy for more time than most guys have available to hunt.  and i've got plenty of friends in the same situation that hunt my home unit and those around it that are able to kill all of their deer each year and very seldom need to hunt posted land. 

maybe i am naive.  or just lucky.  or hunt areas that seem to have avoided the attention of most.  or all of the above.  it just seems to me like there is a heck of a lot of bitching and whining going on the last few weeks.  and tis sad... but, i can only assume its the darn antler envy that's getting to everyone.  i think we just need to step back... take a deep breath... and realize its about more than just killing a deer that belongs on the wall every year... and maybe be happy for the guy that does.  will be thankful when this weekend is over and these posts finally subside. 
Re: Giving Up
by on 11/18/2010 11:16 AM | Reply #20 | "Quote" | "Quick Reply" |

Joined: 01/16/2006
Location: ND
You guys are all arguing over a moot point.  Enjoy the CRP while its here.  I would bet money that CRP is not included in the next farm bill.  Most of the stories I have read about deficit reduction always include cutting stuff from the farm bill.

If you think deer numbers and crazy people are bad this year wait until there is no habitat.
Posted By:
Posted On: 11/17/2010 8:59 PM
2005 Views, 24 Comments

Tags: rifle, season, giving, others, sure, divide, reading, thread, confirms, replies
More Tags: car accident, game warden, Colorado,
Region: North Dakota

Categories: Hunting > Deer Hunting
Rate This ForumTopic
  • Currently 5/5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

5/5 (1 votes cast)

You must be signed in to comment on this topic