243 For Elk?

Pages

61 posts / 0 new
Last post
Eastwood's picture
Eastwood
Offline
GREENHORN
Joined: 12/11/09
243 For Elk?

I'm planning an elk hunt in montana this fall and a couple of buddies of mine say I need more gun than my  Win 243. I have no trouble killing deer with the gun and I'm used to it. Elk can't be any harder to bring down than a deer. What do you guys/girls think?

huntingfanatic's picture
huntingfanatic
Offline
Joined: 3/18/08

 270 or higher.

shocker's picture
shocker
Offline
Joined: 11/10/09

lots of people shoot elk with 243 just depends on the distance you will be shooting

Meelosh's picture
Meelosh
Offline
GREENHORN
Joined: 5/26/06

There was a video on here not too long ago of a person dropping an elk in its tracks at 600+. Shot placement is everything.

Is it impious to weigh goose music and art in the same scales? I think not, because the true hunter is merely a noncreative artist. Who painted the first picture on a bone in the caves of France? A hunter. Who alone in our modern life so thrills to the sight of living beauty that he will endure hunger and thirst and cold to feed his eye upon it? The hunter. Who wrote the great hunter's poem about the sheer wonder of the wind, the hail, and the snow, the stars, the lightnings, and the clouds, the lion, the deer, and the wild goat, the raven, the hawk, and the eagle, and above all the eulogy to the horse? Job, one of the great dramatic artists of all time. Poets sing and hunters scale the mountains primarily for one and the same reason--the thrill of beauty. Critics write and hunters outwit their game primarily for one and the same reason--to reduce that beauty to possession. The differences are largely matters of degree, consciousness, and that sly arbiter of the classification of human activities, language. If, then, we can live without goose music, we may as well do away with stars, or sunsets, or Iliads. But the point is we would be fools to do away with any of them. 

fire angel's picture
fire angel
Offline
Joined: 7/15/03

 Personally I would not hunt Elk with anything smaller than a .270.

TrophyTaker's picture
TrophyTaker
Offline
Joined: 9/21/11

270 or bigger IMO

NodakAngler1's picture
NodakAngler1
Offline
Joined: 7/26/10

Eastwood Said: Elk can't be any harder to bring down than a deer. What do you guys/girls think?

Seriously? 7-800 pound animal (big bull), built to withstand the environment, predators, and terrain of the mountains.   Not saying a .243 cant in the right hands, but based on your above statement I would guess you're probably not that seasoned.

John Browning=GENIUS
NDA Rocks!

shocker's picture
shocker
Offline
Joined: 11/10/09

i agree big tough animal my buddy shot one in CO and had her laying down bout 10 yds from him and so much blood you wouldnt have thought she could get up but she did and we never found her...was thick oak brush and he shot her with 338 ultra mag...made us sick we couldnt find her

Horsager's picture
Horsager
Offline
Joined: 8/12/03

 Will the 243Win work?  Yes.  Will a 270 or something even larger work better?  Yes.

I've killed 7 elk.  6 via 300Win mag, 1 via 257 Wby.  I've witnessed 3 more killed.  2 via 300Win mag, 1 via 270Win.

I wouldn't use the 257Wby again if I had other choices.  The 270Win did an outstanding job, shot through the lungs had the cow on the turf in about 10sec.  The 300Wins were even better.

Unless I had no other choice, I wouldn't spend the $1K for a MT tag and haul along a 243Win.  If they've got something lined up for you on a private ranch where the elk come down out of the mountains and present you with a standing 200yd shot out in the open, by all means, take your 243.

This moment is a paradox, it's the oldest you've ever been as well as the youngest you'll ever be.



ggenthusiast's picture
ggenthusiast
Offline
Joined: 9/11/02

If you do use a .243, do the elk a favor and at least use a Barnes/GMX-type bullet in case you hit it in the shoulder.  A ballistic tip or SST would most likely leave a big pock-mark and bounce off.

I say to hell with that pot o' gold.

bunnyhunter's picture
bunnyhunter
Offline
Joined: 9/14/10

I know the .243 isn't legal in ND for Elk. Not sure about Montana though.

NodakAngler1's picture
NodakAngler1
Offline
Joined: 7/26/10

ggenthusiast Said:
If you do use a .243, do the elk a favor and at least use a Barnes/GMX-type bullet in case you hit it in the shoulder.  A ballistic tip or SST would most likely leave a big pock-mark and bounce off.

This right here is why I wouldn't use a .243 in anything but the most controlled shot. .243 to the shoulder will take out one lung if you're lucky, unfortunately with something as tough as an elk you probably just lost your prize.

John Browning=GENIUS
NDA Rocks!

Eastwood's picture
Eastwood
Offline
GREENHORN
Joined: 12/11/09

ggenthusiast Said:
If you do use a .243, do the elk a favor and at least use a Barnes/GMX-type bullet in case you hit it in the shoulder.  A ballistic tip or SST would most likely leave a big pock-mark and bounce off.

I shoot 100 gr. Partioned Noslers

Steve

ndbwhunter's picture
ndbwhunter
Offline
Joined: 2/23/05

Unless you're willing to buy something bigger than a 270, do the elk a favor and dont go! Shot placement is critical no matter what caliber you are shooting, but the margin of error with a 243 is much lower than with a bigger caliber. Use this trip as an excuse to buy a new gun! Preferably 300 or larger IMO

BOUTDOORS's picture
BOUTDOORS
Offline
Joined: 7/23/10

If you know your shots will be easy and your a lung popper - go for it (just not in ND) as i've seen guys in my party do it without issue.  My opinion is get your hands on a 270 or bigger.  If you are mountain hunting and have a split second shot you'll want something with punch.  I used a 30-06 one year and a 270 two years for elk and tagged out each time.  Heck - take the opportunity to add to the arsenal.  Today i'd go with a 7mm.

KurtR's picture
KurtR
Offline
GREENHORN
Joined: 4/16/07

the old .308 seems to get er done,  if looking magnum i am into the .284 flavors
http://www.snipershide.com/forum/ubbthreads.php?ubb=showflat&Number=3125949#Post3125949

 Adn

taylorman_55's picture
taylorman_55
Offline
GREENHORN
Joined: 2/24/10

 For the sake of the animal, I will borrow you my .270, 7mm, or 7mm Ultra Mag. Of course a .243 will kill an elk. However, with using a smaller caliber, the margin of error is that much less, along with wounding, kill time, etc. Personally a 100 gr. seems light to me for elk. Would much rather see someone in at least that 117-160 grain area for elk. However, thats just my opinion, I am by NO MEANS a caliber expert. 

 

Tacoman's picture
Tacoman
Offline
Joined: 2/13/06

I can catch pike on a bare hook and 2lb test mono, but that doesn't mean that I would target pike with that light of tackle.  Get something .270 or bigger.

taylorman_55's picture
taylorman_55
Offline
GREENHORN
Joined: 2/24/10

Good way of putting it Enslow.  

Enslow Said:
I can catch pike on a bare hook and 2lb test mono, but that doesn't mean that I would target pike with that light of tackle.  Get something .270 or bigger.

 

Horsager's picture
Horsager
Offline
Joined: 8/12/03

 

Enslow Said:
I can catch pike on a bare hook

BS!

This moment is a paradox, it's the oldest you've ever been as well as the youngest you'll ever be.



tearbear's picture
tearbear
Offline
GREENHORN
Joined: 11/12/07

Perfect shot, perfect conditions, on a small elk, yep a 243 might get it done. How about a big bull of a lifetime,  at long range in not so perfect conditions? Your chances are slim to none. The right equipment is always better than going half assed, which is exactly what you would be doing. Argue all you want, but my recommendation is to carry as much gun as you can handle efficiently!

NodakAngler1's picture
NodakAngler1
Offline
Joined: 7/26/10

tearbear Said:
Perfect shot, perfect conditions, on a small elk, yep a 243 might get it done. How about a big bull of a lifetime,  at long range in not so perfect conditions? Your chances are slim to none. The right equipment is always better than going half assed, which is exactly what you would be doing. Argue all you want, but my recommendation is to carry as much gun as you can handle efficiently!

Well put.

John Browning=GENIUS
NDA Rocks!

327's picture
327
Offline
Joined: 8/25/10

 I have to agree why take the chance of wounding an animal because you are using the wrong gun.  enough other things can go wrong I would hate to have to small of a caliber be to blame.  What ever you decide though good luck.

 

marksman's picture
marksman
Offline
Joined: 11/21/05

Eastwood Said:
I'm planning an elk hunt in montana this fall and a couple of buddies of mine say I need more gun than my  Win 243. I have no trouble killing deer with the gun and I'm used to it. Elk can't be any harder to bring down than a deer. What do you guys/girls think?

243 loaded with a 105 gr. turning hard will do the job at 300 yds IF you have the right gun that will stabilize the 105 pushing it hard is a really good combination.. 25-06 has no problem with moose and elk pushing 100 gr.

The best democrat platform a Republican can stand on it a manure pile

drug test everyone on welfare

have an open season on molesters

NodakAngler1's picture
NodakAngler1
Offline
Joined: 7/26/10

marksman Said
243 loaded with a 105 gr. turning hard will do the job at 300 yds IF you have the right gun that will stabilize the 105 pushing it hard is a really good combination.. 25-06 has no problem with moose and elk pushing 100 gr.

What rate of twist are you talking for the .243?

John Browning=GENIUS
NDA Rocks!

Horsager's picture
Horsager
Offline
Joined: 8/12/03

 

huntorride365 Said:

marksman Said
243 loaded with a 105 gr. turning hard will do the job at 300 yds IF you have the right gun that will stabilize the 105 pushing it hard is a really good combination.. 25-06 has no problem with moose and elk pushing 100 gr.

What rate of twist are you talking for the .243?

1:9 or better will get it done with most 105's.

This moment is a paradox, it's the oldest you've ever been as well as the youngest you'll ever be.



NodakAngler1's picture
NodakAngler1
Offline
Joined: 7/26/10

Horsager Said:
 


1:9 or better will get it done with most 105's.

Ok. Just bought Rem 700 sps varmint, has the 26" barrel, believe 1-9 1/4 twist. Thought was a longer range coyote rig for me, and then let the daughter use it for deer. The more I think about it, even though it will be heavy, I think it will be a great antelope rifle for me, if it will stabilize the bigger bullets.

John Browning=GENIUS
NDA Rocks!

Horsager's picture
Horsager
Offline
Joined: 8/12/03

 105 A-Max might work.

This moment is a paradox, it's the oldest you've ever been as well as the youngest you'll ever be.



marksman's picture
marksman
Offline
Joined: 11/21/05

243 100 gr      .244 dia   3100fps
25-06  100gr   .257 dia   3350 fps
270  130 gr      .277dia   3050  fps

there is only .033 difference in total diameter less than the thickness of a dime

So what makes the 270 better     will a 270 kill better with the same placed shot than a 243

energy at 200 yds
243 1457
25-05 1508
270 1788
 this is from the hornady third edition
   It looks like a horse apeice   I would assume that more shooting with the 243 would do more than a new gun that you are not used to. 

The best democrat platform a Republican can stand on it a manure pile

drug test everyone on welfare

have an open season on molesters

NodakAngler1's picture
NodakAngler1
Offline
Joined: 7/26/10

Horsager Said:
 105 A-Max might work.

Alright, thanks. Should have it set up in the next week. Then workin on the Montana in .308, think that will be all the wife will allow for this year, anything else (another 1911 would be nice) and I'll be sleeping in the loft of my garage.

John Browning=GENIUS
NDA Rocks!

JLDII's picture
JLDII
Offline
Joined: 3/8/11

Elk are damn tough animals. Real lead packers. If they were carnivorous, not many men would walk in the woods alone.

My first choice is a 300Win. after that a .270 Mag, .308 or 30-06. It comes down to hitting them with the heaviest weight you can. Nothing below 150gr in my opinion.

My buddy dropped a real nice bull in Co. 2 years ago with a high shoulder shot at 572 yards. Folded him in his tracks with a 300Win. shooting 180gr Barnes.

Jack Dunn

Life is like sex, you can either lay back and let it screw you, or get on top and ride the hell out of it!

Pages